Could trilobites thrive in changing environments? The story behind our study of Cambrian ecosystems

Published in Materials

Could trilobites thrive in changing environments? The story behind our study of Cambrian ecosystems

Share this post

Choose a social network to share with, or copy the URL to share elsewhere

This is a representation of how your post may appear on social media. The actual post will vary between social networks

The question that started it all

The discovery of trilobites with exceptionally preserved three-dimensional (3D) anatomy in Morocco opened an unexpected window into the Cambrian world. Rapid burial by volcanic ash, carried by a pyroclastic flow into a shallow-marine environment, preserved exquisite details of their appendages and digestive system. Beyond revealing anatomy rarely accessible in the fossil record, this discovery highlighted volcanic ash deposits in marine settings as an underexplored source of exceptionally preserved organisms.

But it also raised a new question: what environmental conditions did these trilobites inhabit, and could we reliably reconstruct those conditions in volcaniclastic rocks?

Answering this question was not straightforward. The same volcanic processes responsible for their exceptional preservation could also have influenced the geochemical signals we needed to interpret their environment. We therefore had to determine which proxies could provide reliable environmental information and which might lead to misleading conclusions.

When the results challenged our expectations

Trilobites are iconic inhabitants of ancient marine ecosystems. Given their marine affinity and the shallow-marine setting in which the fossils were preserved, we initially expected the geochemical evidence to indicate relatively high salinity. Instead, our results pointed towards much lower salinity, approaching freshwater conditions.

This was an unexpected finding. Could these trilobites have inhabited environments influenced by freshwater input, or were we detecting a misleading geochemical signal caused by volcanic activity?

Answering this question required us to look beyond the fossils themselves and critically assess the geochemical proxies used to reconstruct their environment. The volcanic processes that contributed to their exceptional preservation could also have modified the chemical signals preserved in the rocks. Distinguishing the original environmental signal from these potential volcanic overprints became one of the main challenges of our study. This was particularly important because the proxies we were investigating had not previously been applied in this specific context. Rather than relying on a single indicator, we used multiple salinity and redox proxies and compared their results with one another. We also compared three groups of samples: purely sedimentary rocks, sedimentary rocks with a volcanic contribution, and samples of pure volcanic ash, as trilobites have also been found below and above the trilobite ash level. We also used a basalt from the same volcano as an additional geochemical reference. For each proxy, we examined boxplots and the distribution of individual measurements along the stratigraphic succession to assess how the geochemical signals varied between sample types and with depth. The comparisons revealed that volcanic material could slightly dilute some of the geochemical proxies. However, the magnitude of this effect was limited and did not substantially alter the environmental interpretation. In particular, the salinity proxies continued to indicate comparable low-salinity conditions in both the volcanically influenced samples and the purely sedimentary samples, consistent with brackish to freshwater-influenced environments. This was a crucial step in our investigation. Rather than assuming that the volcanic influence had no effect, we evaluated whether its impact was large enough to change the conclusions drawn from the geochemical data. The agreement between the sedimentary and mixed samples gave us greater confidence that the low-salinity signal was not simply an artefact of volcanic input.

Once the geochemical evidence had been critically evaluated, the low-salinity signal offered a new perspective on the environment in which these trilobites lived. Our interpretation points towards a deltaic setting influenced by freshwater input, with fluctuations in salinity. Rather than imagining a uniformly marine environment with consistently high salinity, we must consider a more dynamic landscape in which marine waters interacted with freshwater. Such environmental variability raises important questions about the ecological flexibility of Cambrian organisms. The success of trilobites may have been linked not only to their ability to thrive in marine ecosystems but also, in some settings, to their capacity to tolerate changing environmental conditions. By combining paleontological evidence with geochemical reconstruction, our study provides a more nuanced view of the environments associated with these exceptionally preserved trilobites and of the ecological conditions that may have shaped their history.

Follow the Topic

Biomaterials
Physical Sciences > Materials Science > Biomaterials