Ruth Beutler: the woman behind Karl von Frisch

Ruth Beutler, the first woman to publish an article in the Journal of Comparative Physiology A in 1924, made notable contributions to comparative physiology and zoology despite facing discrimination and marginalization in her field.
Published in Ecology & Evolution
Ruth Beutler: the woman behind Karl von Frisch
Like

Share this post

Choose a social network to share with, or copy the shortened URL to share elsewhere

This is a representation of how your post may appear on social media. The actual post will vary between social networks

Read the paper

SpringerLink
SpringerLink SpringerLink

Ruth Beutler: the woman behind Karl von Frisch - Journal of Comparative Physiology A

The Journal of Comparative Physiology A was founded in 1924 as the Zeitschrift für vergleichende Physiologie by Karl von Frisch and Alfred Kühn. Given the marginalization of women in science at that time, it is remarkable that the first article in the Journal was authored by a female scientist, Ruth Beutler. Throughout her scientific career, she was affiliated with the Zoological Institute of the University of Munich, which, under the leadership of von Frisch, evolved into a world-class academic institution. Despite chronic health problems, Beutler was one of the first women who succeeded in obtaining the Habilitation as qualification for appointment to a professorial position. She was also one of the first scientists who applied methods from physiological chemistry to the study of zoological phenomena. Yet, for many years she was employed as a technician only, and she was never appointed to an Ordinarius (tenured full professorship) position. Her most important contributions to comparative physiology outside her own area of research were her support for, and protection of, Karl von Frisch, particularly during the Nazi era when he, as a ‘quarter-Jew,’ faced imminent threat of forced retirement; and after World War II, when her efforts as interim Ordinarius were instrumental in re-building the bombed-out Zoological Institute to persuade Karl von Frisch to return to Munich. It was also one of her observations that prompted him to revisit, and revise, his earlier (incorrect) model of how honeybees communicate, through their dances, the direction and distances of food sources from the hive.

The story of Ruth Beutler (1897-1959), the first female scientist to publish an article in the Journal of Comparative Physiology A back in 1924, highlights the importance of women in science. Despite facing marginalization and discrimination in her field, Beutler made significant contributions to comparative physiology and zoology. Her success in obtaining the Habilitation and her support for Karl von Frisch during a difficult period demonstrate the resilience and determination of women scientists.

Ruth Beutler was a complex figure, a woman who overcame severe disabilities to receive an education that was only available to the privileged few. She combined her education with exceptional experimental skills, motivation, and perseverance, becoming one of the first women in Germany to be awarded the Habilitation. Her pioneering work included applying methods from physiological chemistry to the study of zoological phenomena.

Ruth Beutler and Karl von Frisch (circa 1950)

Despite her impressive qualifications and research record, Beutler faced obstacles in her career. For several years, she was only employed as a technician, and when the position of Ordinarius at Munich was vacant, her name was not considered as a potential successor to Karl von Frisch. It is unclear whether she had any ambitions to become Ordinarius, but her priority was to rebuild the Zoological Institute and make it attractive enough for von Frisch to return.

During her lifetime, women in leadership roles were rare, and their appointments were often met with resistance. Beutler herself faced difficulties as interim Ordinarius to be treated equally by her Munich colleagues. However, there is no evidence that she sympathized with the women's rights movement or was a feminist. Her role, as she saw it, was to support and protect von Frisch and accept him as her superior and intellectual leader.

During the Nazi regime, Beutler played a crucial role in carrying out a project called nosemosis, which had little potential for scientific advancement and was aimed at saving von Frisch from forced retirement. However, her observation on bee communication through dances resulted in the discovery of the 'dance language' model, which established von Frisch as the discoverer of the bee dance language. Although von Frisch was already an accomplished experimenter, Beutler's observation might have hastened the revision of the model by prompting him to test his original hypothesis earlier than he would have otherwise.

Karl von Frisch (1886-1982), was an Austrian-German ethologist who shared the 1973 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Nikolaas Tinbergen and Konrad Lorenz. His research focused on investigating the sensory perceptions of honey bees and was notable for his interpretation of the meaning behind the waggle dance. Despite skepticism and opposition from other scientists at the time, his theory, as described in his 1927 book Aus dem Leben der Bienen (translated into English as The Dancing Bees), was later proven to be an accurate theoretical analysis.

The Journal of Comparative Physiology A was founded in 1924 as the Zeitschrift für vergleichende Physiologie by Karl von Frisch and Alfred Kühn, as the first publication platform for comparative physiology studies when the field was still in its early stages. Although the field was dominated by male scholars at the time, the first article published in the journal was authored by Ruth Beutler, a notable female scientist, which is a testament to her groundbreaking contributions. However, despite the journal publishing nearly ten thousand articles over a century, Beutler's name remains largely unrecognized by most comparative physiologists.


To know more about Ruth Beutler and her role in von Frisch's work, read the historical review article written by the journal's Editor in Chief here: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00359-023-01622-0

The original article from Ruth Beutler published in 1924 can be found here: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF00338209

Please sign in or register for FREE

If you are a registered user on Research Communities by Springer Nature, please sign in