Short Discussion on Rashid Khalidi's "Hundred Years' War on Palestine"

Dr Rashid Khalidi's "The Hundred Years War for Palestine" looks at the complex geopolitical and territorial factors driving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and challenges conventional accounts.
Short Discussion on Rashid Khalidi's "Hundred Years' War on Palestine"
Like

Share this post

Choose a social network to share with, or copy the shortened URL to share elsewhere

This is a representation of how your post may appear on social media. The actual post will vary between social networks

Rashid Khalidi's "Hundred Years War for Palestine" is an important book that helps us understand the Israeli-Palestinian conflict by looking at it through history and geography. Dr. Khalidi's history, beginning with the Balfour Declaration in 1917 to the present day, shows how settler colonialism, the formation of national identities and geopolitical actions have shaped the ongoing conflict in Palestine. Rather than simply recounting events, Khalidi explains the spatial and political forces that have driven the conflict, making his book an indispensable tool for understanding the complex layers of this struggle.
Dr. Khalidi not only enumerates historical events, but explores the spatial and political aspects that keep the conflict going. Using archives and family histories, he provides a detailed overview of the centuries-long colonization efforts against the Palestinians that began with the Zionist movement and were continued by Israel with British and American support. The book begins with a moving letter from the mayor of Jerusalem, Yusuf Diya al-Khalidi, warning of the dangers of expulsion and calling for the protection of Palestine.
The book carefully describes key moments in Palestinian history such as the Balfour Declaration, the Nakba in 1948 and the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1982. Khalidi avoids portraying the Palestinians only as victims and instead sheds light on the complex mix of resistance and leadership failures. This approach challenges existing views and encourages a fresh look at historical events and political strategies.
Khalidi also explores the geopolitical motivations and ideological trends driving the conflict. He critically examines the inconsistent support from neighboring Arab states and points to instances of betrayal such as King Abdullah's collaboration with Zionist forces in the annexation of the West Bank. This highlights the complicated regional politics influencing the Palestinian struggle.
The narrative looks at the deceptive ideologies within the Zionist movement and discusses the influence of extremist views such as those of Rabbi Meir Kahane on Israeli politics. Khalidi draws parallels between historical Zionist tactics and modern political strategies and shows that security and historical claims always conceal territorial ambitions. This theme becomes clear in his analysis of diplomatic agreements such as the Camp David and Oslo Accords, which he argues have often led to further disillusionment among Palestinians.
A large part of Khalidi's work deals with the spatial strategies employed by both Israeli and Palestinian groups. He emphasizes the strategic use of space in the conflict, from settler practices to resistance efforts, and highlights the importance of understanding these dynamics in order to comprehend the persistence of the conflict and find just solutions. His analysis, rooted in political geography, provides a solid framework for exploring the territorial and identity-related aspects of the struggle.
Khalidi also addresses how media and propaganda shape the narrative of the conflict, referencing figures, who have pointed out the challenges of portraying the Palestinian struggle amidst widespread Israeli propaganda. This struggle over narratives is crucial as the control of information significantly influences global perceptions and the legitimacy of territorial claims.
Drawing on historical analogies to illuminate contemporary issues of conflict, he compares British tactics during the Arab Revolt to their actions in Ireland, highlighting the continual use of colonial strategies to control resistance and maintain dominance. These comparisons provide a broader context for understanding the methods and motivations of the various actors in the conflict.
Dr. Khalidi also examines the role of Christian Zionism in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and sheds light on the complex relationship between religious beliefs and geopolitical goals. He discusses the influence of figures such as Lord Shaftesbury and evangelical support for a Jewish homeland, and shows how religious ideologies have shaped geopolitical strategies and contributed to the dispossession of Palestinian land.
Dr. Khalidi's book is more than a historical account; it's an important tool for understanding the spatial and geopolitical dimensions of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. By incorporating political geography into his analysis, he offers a nuanced perspective that challenges traditional narratives and provides new insights into settler colonialism, resistance and national identity formation. By focusing on the spatial aspects of the conflict, Dr. Khalidi emphasizes the importance of geography in shaping political contestation and the potential for developing more effective conflict resolution strategies.
And so Dr. Rashid Khalidi's "One Hundred Years War for Palestine" is a must-read for anyone who wants to understand the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. His detailed research and incisive analysis provide a comprehensive overview of the historical and spatial dynamics shaping the Palestinian struggle for self-determination. By crossing traditional boundaries and using political geography, Dr. Khalidi's work contributes to a better understanding of the conflict and provides valuable insights to tackle its complexity. The book's interdisciplinary approach is a model for future research and emphasizes the crucial importance of spatial factors in the study of geopolitical conflict.

credit to ChatGPT
Caption

And we want to add that Dr. Khalidi’s work is a treasure trove for researchers in geopolitics and political geography and offers several important insights:
- The book emphasizes the importance of studying how historical events are intimately intertwined with spatial dynamics. Understanding the geographical strategies of both colonial and resistance movements demonstrates how control over territory influences political outcomes.
- Dr. Khalidi highlights the long-lasting effects of settler colonialism and the ways in which colonial politics continue to shape contemporary conflicts. This provides a framework for analyzing other regions with similar colonial histories.
- The book shows how ideological narratives and media representations shape geopolitical perceptions and policies. Researchers can examine how these narratives influence international support and intervention in conflicts.
- Dr. Khalidi’s analysis of national identity formation among Israelis and Palestinians illustrates the complex processes involved in constructing and contesting national identities. This is important for understanding how identity politics influence territorial conflicts.
- When reading Khalidi’s book, students should pay close attention to the historical context in which each event takes place. Understanding the background is important to grasp the broader geopolitical implications.
- Analyze the sources that Khalidi uses, such as archival documents and personal testimonies. Consider how these sources contribute to the narrative and what they reveal about the perspectives of the different actors involved in the conflict.
- Apply theories of political geography to Khalidi’s analysis. For example, consider how concepts such as territoriality, spatial control and the geopolitics of identity are illustrated by the events and strategies described in the book.
- Compare the Israeli-Palestinian conflict with other global conflicts that have similar spatial and geopolitical dynamics. This can lead to a deeper understanding of the common patterns and unique aspects of each conflict.
- Consider how Khalidi’s insights can be applied to current geopolitical issues. Consider how the spatial strategies and political maneuvers discussed in the book can inform our understanding of contemporary territorial disputes and conflicts.
All in all, Dr. Rashid Khalidi’s "Hundred Years War for Palestine" is an invaluable text for anyone interested in geopolitics and political geography. It offers deep insights into the spatial and geopolitical dimensions of one of the most enduring conflicts in modern history. By critically engaging with the book, students and researchers can improve their understanding of how geography shapes political conflict and the importance of incorporating spatial analysis into geopolitical research.

Further Readings:

1. Agnew, J. A. (2014). The Power of Place (RLE Social & Cultural Geography). Routledge.
   - This book discusses the significance of place in social science, which is crucial for understanding spatial dynamics in conflicts.

2. Alatout, S. (2006). Towards a bio-territorial conception of power: Territory, population, and environmental narratives in Palestine and Israel. Political Geography, 25(6), 601-621.
   - This paper explores the intersection of territoriality, population, and environmental narratives, providing a deeper understanding of spatial dynamics in Palestine and Israel.

3. Belloc, H. (1992). The Crisis of Civilization. Tan Books.
   - Belloc’s work offers insights into historical movements and their relevance to contemporary conflicts.

4. **Bradshaw, T. (2012). Britain and Jordan: Imperial Strategy, King Abdullah I and the Zionist Movement. Bloomsbury Publishing.
   - This book provides an in-depth look at the geopolitical strategies involving Britain, Jordan, and the Zionist movement.

5. Caplan, N. (1977). Arab-Jewish Contacts in Palestine after the First World War. Journal of Contemporary History, 12(4), 635–668.
   - Caplan’s article explores early interactions between Arabs and Jews in Palestine, shedding light on the origins of the conflict.

6. Divine, D. R. (2020). Britain's Pacification of Palestine: The British Army, the Colonial State, and the Arab Revolt, 1936–1939 by Matthew Hughes, and The Hundred Years' War on Palestine: A History of Settler Colonialism and Resistance, 1917–2017 by Rashid Khalidi. The Middle East Journal, 74(1), 134-136.
   - This review provides a comparative analysis of works discussing British colonial strategies and their impact on Palestine.

7. El-Affendi, A. (2024). The Futility of Genocide Studies After Gaza. Journal of Genocide Research, 1-7.
   - El-Affendi’s paper offers a critical perspective on genocide studies in the context of Gaza, relevant for understanding modern conflict dynamics.

8. Hasan, D., & Bleibleh, S. (2023).. The everyday art of resistance: Interpreting "resistancescapes" against urban violence in Palestine. Political Geography, 101, 102833.
   - This article examines the forms of everyday resistance in Palestine, providing insights into the spatial aspects of resistance movements.

9. Hedges, C. (2001). The New Palestinian Revolt. Foreign Affairs, 80(1), 124–138.
   - Chris Hedges’ article explores contemporary Palestinian resistance, relevant for understanding modern political dynamics.

10. Hoffman, B. (2020). The bombing of The King David Hotel, July 1946. Small Wars & Insurgencies, 31(3), 594-611.
    - This paper analyzes a significant event in the history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, providing insights into tactics and responses.

11. Klagsbrun, F. (2017). Lioness: Golda Meir and the Nation of Israel. Schocken.
    - A comprehensive biography of Golda Meir, offering insights into her role in the formation and politics of Israel.

12. Kuzar, R. (2008). The term return in the Palestinian discourse on the Right of Return. Discourse & Society, 19(5), 629-644.
    - This article examines the discourse surrounding the Palestinian Right of Return, a crucial aspect of the conflict.

13. Lewis, D. M. (2010). The Origins of Christian Zionism*. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
    - Lewis’s book explores the roots and impact of Christian Zionism on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

14. Lindqvist, S. (2003). A History of Bombing. The New Press.
    - Lindqvist’s work provides a historical perspective on the use of aerial bombing, relevant for understanding its impact on civilian populations.

15. Siniver, A. (2015). Abba Eban and the Development of American–Israeli Relations, 1950–1959. Diplomacy & Statecraft, 26(1), 65-83.
    - This article explores the development of American-Israeli relations, providing context for geopolitical dynamics.

16. Tal, A. (2016). - The Two-State Delusion: Israel and Palestine—A Tale of Two Narratives. Israel Journal of Foreign Affairs, 10(1), 119-123.
    - Tal’s article critically examines the two-state solution narrative in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

17. Velednitsky, S., Hughes, S. N., & Machold, R. (2020). Political geographical perspectives on settler colonialism. Geography Compass, 14(6), e12490.
    - This paper offers a geographical perspective on settler colonialism, relevant for understanding the spatial dynamics of the conflict.

18. Wolffe, J. (2016). The Origins of Christian Zionism: Lord Shaftesbury and Evangelical Support for a Jewish Homeland. Ecclesiology, 12(3), 390-391.
    - Wolffe’s review provides insights into the historical roots of Christian Zionism and its influence on contemporary geopolitics.

Please sign in or register for FREE

If you are a registered user on Research Communities by Springer Nature, please sign in

Follow the Topic

Human Geography
Humanities and Social Sciences > Society > Population and Demography > Human Geography
International Humanitarian Law, Law of Armed Conflict
Humanities and Social Sciences > Law > Public International Law > International Humanitarian Law, Law of Armed Conflict
Peace and Conflict Studies
Humanities and Social Sciences > Politics and International Studies > International Relations > Peace and Conflict Studies