Behind the Paper, From the Editors

JMCR: Highlight

When the Eyes Reveal a Brainstem Wiring Disorder Before the Spine Begins to Curve

An infant unable to track horizontally had no scoliosis and an otherwise focused neurological examination. Characteristic brainstem MRI findings and molecular testing revealed horizontal gaze palsy with progressive scoliosis before its skeletal manifestation had appeared.

Explore the Research

When an eye-movement abnormality localizes the diagnosis

An 8-month-old boy was referred because he could not track moving targets. Examination demonstrated bilateral horizontal gaze palsy, with preserved vertical gaze and pupillary responses. Ptosis, nystagmus, facial weakness, and spinal deformity were absent.

This pattern immediately localizes the clinical problem. Preserved vertical movements with impaired conjugate horizontal gaze suggests dysfunction of the pontine pathways coordinating horizontal eye movement rather than a generalized ocular motor disorder.

MRI supplied the next clue.

A split pons and butterfly-shaped medulla

Brain MRI demonstrated pontine hypoplasia with a midline cleft—the “split pons” sign—and a butterfly-like configuration of the medulla. Spinal MRI was normal.

These findings reflect abnormal crossing of selected hindbrain axonal pathways and are strongly associated with horizontal gaze palsy with progressive scoliosis. Their presence reframed the absent scoliosis: instead of arguing against the diagnosis, the normal spine suggested that the neurological manifestation had preceded the expected orthopedic one.

Targeted sequencing identified a homozygous ROBO3 nonsense variant, NM_022370.3:c.1450C>T (p.Arg484Ter), which the testing laboratory classified as pathogenic using ACMG/AMP criteria. Each parent was heterozygous.

A diagnosis whose name describes its future

Horizontal gaze palsy with progressive scoliosis is an autosomal-recessive disorder associated with impaired midline crossing of hindbrain pathways. Horizontal gaze impairment is generally congenital; scoliosis typically develops later and may progress substantially during childhood or adolescence.

At 20 months of age—12 months after the first assessment—the child’s gaze palsy remained unchanged and scoliosis had still not developed. This short follow-up cannot establish that scoliosis will occur, but its absence does not invalidate the molecular and radiological diagnosis.

The report therefore illustrates an important temporal principle: in genetically defined progressive disorders, a patient need not yet display every feature contained in the syndrome’s name.

Why early recognition matters

Recognizing the syndrome provides an explanation for the eye-movement abnormality, allows appropriate genetic counselling, and supports prospective orthopedic surveillance rather than waiting for a clinically obvious spinal curvature.

The reported variant was not previously listed in the population databases or ClinVar resources reviewed by the authors. Its apparent novelty should be interpreted cautiously: this is a single family, and future classification should incorporate additional cases, segregation evidence, and evolving database information.

Clinical Take-Home Message

Congenital bilateral horizontal gaze palsy with preserved vertical gaze should prompt careful brainstem imaging.

A midline pontine cleft and butterfly-shaped medulla may strongly suggest horizontal gaze palsy with progressive scoliosis and justify ROBO3 testing—even when spinal examination and imaging are still normal.

The absence of scoliosis during infancy does not exclude this progressive syndrome. Early diagnosis creates an opportunity for genetic counselling and longitudinal orthopedic surveillance before deformity becomes clinically apparent.

Journal of Medical Case Reports is the world’s first international, PubMed-listed medical journal devoted to publishing case reports from all medical disciplines and will consider any original case report that expands the field of general medical knowledge, and original research relating to case reports. The journal is open access and strongly endorses the CARE guidelines for case reports, requiring authors to submit populated CARE checklists with submissions to improve transparency in reporting.

Explore the original report: Javaid MH, Khan AI, Ali T, et al. Genetically confirmed horizontal gaze palsy with progressive scoliosis syndrome diagnosed at 8 months before the development of scoliosis: a case report. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13256-026-06811-4

AI disclosure: Artificial intelligence tools were used to assist with drafting, language editing and generating the accompanying illustrations. The author reviewed and edited the content, verified the clinical information against the cited publications, and takes full responsibility for the final post.