Designing and Analyzing Drone-Based City Logistics Solutions

Our exploration of drone-based logistics for Kochi aimed to tackle critical urban challenges. This journey of inquiry, collaboration, and resilience led to insights that could transform city logistics, blending innovation with purpose from conception to publication.
Published in Mechanical Engineering
Designing and Analyzing Drone-Based City Logistics Solutions
Like

Share this post

Choose a social network to share with, or copy the URL to share elsewhere

This is a representation of how your post may appear on social media. The actual post will vary between social networks

Read the paper

SpringerLink
SpringerLink SpringerLink

Designing and analyzing drone-based city logistics solutions for Kochi using a Fuzzy Multi-Criteria decision making framework - Environment, Development and Sustainability

Over the past decades, city logistics (CL) problems have led to the development of sustainable solutions and approaches. Current last-mile operations are inefficient, and economic competitiveness is influenced by limited time windows for freight delivery in complex urban environments. Technological innovations and CL initiatives have enabled the development of novel, complex, and sustainable solutions. Unmanned aerial vehicles (drones) have gained attention in literature, and this paper aims to evaluate and find the most suitable drone-based CL concept for Kochi city in Kerala, India. Considering the city’s geography, 11 feasible drone-based CL concepts are identified and evaluated by applying F-CoCoSo (Fuzzy Combined Compromise Solution) method. The fuzzy Sugeno-Weber operator is used to aggregate the expert opinions. The results imply that the best ranked alternatives are A3 (Barges acting as mobile depots for drone launching for delivery zones near to inland waterways and MCCs for services outside delivery zones), and A9 (Barges acting as mobile depots, transporting goods to generator groups, with drones executing final delivery phases). This article provides insights into the potential of drone applications in CL concepts, offering guidance for future policymakers and planners in defining development directions in urban areas. It also inspires the use of emerging technologies and known CL initiatives in defining new CL concepts. The approach also helps decision-makers address CL problems by considering stakeholder interests and incorporating their goals into a comprehensive decision-making framework, ensuring effective CL solutions.

The Genesis of an Idea: The Why Behind the What

The idea was born from a walk through the streets of Kochi, a vibrant port city with a unique blend of bustling commerce, scenic waterways, and congested streets. It struck us that the city’s last-mile delivery operations were chaotic, leading to inefficiencies, pollution, and delays. Meanwhile, its vast network of waterways seemed underutilized for freight.

The question was simple yet bold: Could drones, paired with Kochi’s geography, bring efficiency and sustainability to logistics? From this spark of curiosity, the team began weaving a multi-layered research effort, drawing expertise from logistics, urban planning, and environmental science.

Shaping the Research: From Concept to Framework

Turning an idea into a study meant answering several questions:

  • What criteria matter most in evaluating drone-based city logistics?
  • How can we design models tailored to Kochi’s topography and transport modes?
  • Which decision-making framework balances complexity with practical application?

Months of groundwork followed. A Fuzzy Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) framework was identified to evaluate solutions systematically. We focused on 11 potential logistics models, ranging from ground vehicle-drone hybrids to innovative combinations like drones launched from barges or airships.

Criteria Definition
We established 10 criteria, covering efficiency, environmental impact, and regulatory feasibility. Some criteria, like “freeing public spaces” or “operational complexity,” resonated deeply with local experts, anchoring our research in practical realities. Each criterion was designed to capture the multifaceted challenges of urban logistics.

 

The Highs: Breakthroughs, Collaboration, and Eureka Moments

One breakthrough moment came while applying the Fuzzy Combined Compromise Solution (F-CoCoSo) methodology. Unlike traditional evaluation tools, F-CoCoSo combined fuzzy logic with compromise ranking, handling uncertainties and subjective preferences seamlessly. It illuminated unexpected insights—for example, that barge-based drone systems (Concept A9) offered both ecological and logistical advantages in Kochi's inland waterway-rich geography.

Collaboration proved to be the cornerstone of progress. A panel of six experts with diverse backgrounds—urban planning, logistics, transportation engineering, and environmental policy—ensured our models bridged theory with ground-level realities. Brainstorming sessions often spilled into late evenings, fueled by passionate debates on drone regulations, infrastructure needs, and public acceptance.

Visualization and Mapping
Mapping drone launch points, waterway routes, and delivery zones was another high point. Seeing Kochi’s logistics network reimagined in a way that balanced sustainability and efficiency was a powerful motivator.

 

The Lows: Challenges and Setbacks

Every research journey has its share of trials. For us, data limitations were a significant challenge. Drone logistics is an emerging field, particularly in developing countries, making empirical datasets scarce. We had to rely on simulations, literature reviews, and expert surveys, often refining our assumptions iteratively.

Another obstacle was stakeholder alignment. Different experts brought varied priorities—some favored cost-effective solutions, while others championed environmental considerations. Achieving consensus required repeated deliberations, testing our patience but ultimately strengthening the study.

Regulatory Hurdles
Regulations for drone usage in India added another layer of complexity. Navigating the evolving policy landscape required meticulous attention to detail, as well as proactive engagement with guidelines for drone delivery systems.

 

Publication: From Manuscript to Milestone

After rigorous peer review, our paper, “Designing and Analyzing Drone-Based City Logistics Solutions for Kochi Using a Fuzzy Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Framework,” was published in Environment, Development, and Sustainability. Seeing our findings validated by the academic community was an incredible milestone.

The paper demonstrated that integrating drones with existing modes—such as barge depots or two-phase systems using micro-consolidation centers—offered viable, scalable solutions. Our sensitivity analysis and comparative models provided robust guidance for urban planners and policymakers.

 

Reflections: What We Learned

This journey wasn’t just about algorithms or logistics—it was a lesson in collaboration, perseverance, and the art of balancing competing priorities. We learned that:

  1. Interdisciplinary Collaboration drives innovation. Bringing together diverse perspectives enriched our approach and ensured practical applicability.
  2. Uncertainty Management is crucial. The fuzzy MCDM framework proved invaluable for navigating ambiguities in expert input and city data.
  3. Local Context Matters. Solutions must align with a city’s unique geography, economy, and infrastructure for meaningful impact.

 

What’s Next? Towards Implementation

While this research offers theoretical solutions, implementation is the next frontier. Our immediate plans include:

  • Pilot Studies: Testing barge-based drone systems in select zones to validate feasibility.
  • Policy Engagement: Collaborating with local governments to address regulatory and safety concerns.
  • Public Awareness Campaigns: Engaging the community to foster acceptance and understanding of drone logistics.

The journey also revealed broader questions for future exploration. How can drone logistics integrate with emerging technologies like IoT? What are the ethical implications of automation in urban freight? These questions inspire us to continue pushing boundaries.

 

Closing Thoughts

This paper is more than a contribution to academic literature—it’s a call to action for sustainable urban innovation. For cities like Kochi, where tradition meets modernity, reimagining logistics through drones is not just an opportunity but a necessity.

We hope this glimpse behind the scenes inspires others navigating their own research odysseys. Every challenge faced, every late-night debate, and every breakthrough moment adds depth to the final work. As researchers, it’s not just the destination that matters—it’s the transformative journey that leads us there.

Please sign in or register for FREE

If you are a registered user on Research Communities by Springer Nature, please sign in