Estimation and usefulness of measurement uncertainty from sampling at different spatial scales: microns to kilometres

Measurements made on samples are the basis of most scientific decision, but always contain uncertainty. Much of this uncertainty arises from how the samples are taken, and this can be quantified using the Duplicate Method, which can be applied at any spatial scale, from kilometre to microns.
Like

Share this post

Choose a social network to share with, or copy the URL to share elsewhere

This is a representation of how your post may appear on social media. The actual post will vary between social networks

Explore the Research

SpringerLink
SpringerLink SpringerLink

Estimation and usefulness of measurement uncertainty from sampling at different spatial scales: microns to kilometres - Environmental Geochemistry and Health

Uncertainty of measurement values (MU) is crucial to their reliable geochemical interpretation. MU can be estimated using the Duplicate Method, which requires the taking of a small proportion of duplicated samples, and can be applied at any spatial scale. The distance between the duplicated samples is selected to reflect the effect of analyte heterogeneity on the measurement result (i.e. estimated concentration) within each sampling target, at the particular scale of investigation. Three published case studies, at different spatial scales, are used to explain how the Duplicate Method can be applied to estimate MU. They also illustrate how MU can be used to improve geochemical interpretation and validate measurement procedures (that include sampling) by judging their fitness for purpose. At the kilometre scale, measurements from the GEMAS survey of agricultural soils across Europe are used to estimate their MU for the first time. The MU for 53 elements range from an uncertainty factor of 1.01 to over 10. The MU contributes more that 20% to the total variance for 8 of the 53 elements, showing that the measurement procedure was not fit for purpose in those cases. At the micron scale, measurements of oxygen isotopes in candidate quartz reference materials had MU that was dominated by its sampling component, caused by sometimes unacceptable heterogeneity. A third case study of Pb in soils at 12 UK sites showed that the Duplicate Method can also be used to quantify the heterogeneity (as factor 1.03 to 2.4), and that it can indicate different possible sources of an element.

Uncertainty of measurement values (MU) is crucial to their reliable geochemical interpretation. MU can be estimated using the Duplicate Method, which requires the taking of a small proportion of duplicated samples, and can be applied at any spatial scale. The distance between the duplicated samples is selected to reflect the effect of analyte heterogeneity on the measurement result (i.e. estimated concentration) within each sampling target, at the particular scale of investigation. Three published case studies, at different spatial scales, are used to explain how the Duplicate Method can be applied to estimate MU. They also illustrate how MU can be used to improve geochemical interpretation and validate measurement procedures (that include sampling) by judging their fitness for purpose. At the kilometre scale, measurements from the GEMAS survey of agricultural soils across Europe are used to estimate their MU for the first time. The MU for 53 elements range from an uncertainty factor of 1.01 to over 10. The MU contributes more that 20% to the total variance for 8 of the 53 elements, showing that the measurement procedure was not fit for purpose in those cases.

Effect of increasing levels of measurement uncertainty on clarity of geochemical maps of Europe
Effect of increasing measurement uncertainty on clarity of (GEMAS) geochemical maps of Europe, from acceptably low levels for As, Pb to unacceptably high level for Pt

At the micron scale, measurements of oxygen isotopes in candidate quartz reference materials had MU that was dominated by its sampling component, caused by sometimes unacceptable heterogeneity. A third case study of Pb in soils at 12 UK sites showed that the Duplicate Method can also be used to quantify the heterogeneity (as factor 1.03 to 2.4), and that it can indicate different possible sources of an element. 

https://doi.org/10.1007/s10653-024-01888-6

Please sign in or register for FREE

If you are a registered user on Research Communities by Springer Nature, please sign in

Follow the Topic

Earth Sciences
Physical Sciences > Earth and Environmental Sciences > Earth Sciences
Analytical Chemistry
Physical Sciences > Chemistry > Analytical Chemistry
Measurement Science and Instrumentation
Physical Sciences > Physics and Astronomy > Applied and Technical Physics > Measurement Science and Instrumentation

Related Collections

With Collections, you can get published faster and increase your visibility.

Harnessing Nano-Geo Interfaces: Advancing Geochemical Processes and Mitigating Anthropogenic Contaminants in Ecosystems

This special collection aims to explore the integration of engineered nanomaterials with geochemical processes to address the growing environmental challenges posed by anthropogenic contaminants. It will cover a broad range of topics, including but not limited to:

• Mechanistic Studies: Research on how engineered nanomaterials interact with pollutants like toxic trace metals, pharmaceuticals, microplastics, and other contaminants in complex environmental matrices.

• Functionalized Nanomaterials: Contributions exploring the design and application of functionalized nanomaterials for targeted pollutant capture, transformation, and immobilization in contaminated environment.

• Biogeochemical Interactions: Studies examining the role of nanomaterials in enhancing biogeochemical processes, such as natural attenuation, nutrient cycling, and soil and water quality improvement.

• In Situ Monitoring Techniques: Research on emerging methodologies for real-time monitoring of contaminant transformation, nanoparticle interactions, and the efficacy of nano-enabled remediation technologies across diverse environmental matrices.

• Case Studies and Applications: Practical examples showcasing the successful application of nano-geochemical interfaces in different ecosystems, demonstrating their potential for effective pollution mitigation and enhancing environmental health.

By covering these themes, this special collection will provide a comprehensive overview of the latest advancements in nano-geochemical interfaces, facilitating knowledge exchange and collaboration among researchers and contributing to the development of sustainable solutions for global environmental challenges.

Publishing Model: Hybrid

Deadline: Dec 31, 2025

Interdisciplinary Seawater Monitoring in Multi-Stressor Marine Environments: Implications for Environmental and Human Health

Marine environments are increasingly affected by a combination of natural and anthropogenic stressors, leading to changes in seawater quality that can have direct and indirect impacts on both environmental and human health. Contaminants such as bioaccumulative toxins, marine litter, and emerging chemical pollutants can enter marine food webs, affect biodiversity, and ultimately pose risks to human populations dependent on marine resources.

This Special Issue aims to provide new insights into the complex pathways through which multi-stressor marine environments influence environmental and human health, contributing to a more holistic understanding needed for effective management and policy actions. It will gather research that investigates the interactions between multiple stressors in marine environments and their consequences for ecosystem and human health. It will include contributions on climate related parameters, bio-essential and toxic elements, litter, organic pollutants, biodiversity, radioactivity, frugal monitoring technologies, and citizen science approaches to environmental health surveillance. Emphasis will be placed on interdisciplinary studies that link marine environmental quality indicators to potential health outcomes, risk assessment, stakeholder engagement, and policy recommendations.

Publishing Model: Hybrid

Deadline: Mar 31, 2026