Solution for a long-standing puzzle in polar stratospheric chemistry

A model study identifies a possible cause for the previously not yet understood depletion of hydrogen chloride in early winter in the polar stratosphere.

Published in Earth & Environment

Like

Share this post

Choose a social network to share with, or copy the URL to share elsewhere

This is a representation of how your post may appear on social media. The actual post will vary between social networks

After the discovery of the ozone hole in 1985, the causes of its formation were discovered quite quickly. Chlorine compounds released from emitted CFCs are activated on cold polar stratospheric clouds, followed by catalytic ozone depletion cycles in which one chlorine atom can destroy many ozone molecules.

Nowadays, the atmospheric models that calculate polar ozone depletion in the stratosphere are  able to explain the observed ozone depletion reasonably well. However, based on model-measurement comparison, some details of the chlorine chemistry were not fully understood. The figure below from an earlier publication  demonstrates that the satellite observations show a depletion of hydrogen chloride (HCl) over the pole that is not present in the model simulations.
The simulations do not show the  HCl depletion in the core of the polar vortex over Antarctica that are visible in the satellite data.

MLS observations and CLaMS simulations of HCl mixing ratios
 Observations (left) and previous simulations (right) of HCl mixing ratio for 20 July in about 21 km altitude.
From Grooß et al. (2018)

As several models were unable to correctly reproduce the HCl depletion, it appears that a chemical sink was missing,  which possibly could have consequences on other chlorine trace gases. There were many hypotheses on what this reaction could be, but no convincing possibility had been found so far. After almost giving up trying to find the missing chemistry, we came across two publications from the year 1997 in which the heterogeneous reaction of chlorine peroxide (Cl2O2) with hydrogen chloride was investigated in a laboratory study  with estimation of its impact explored in a  simplified box-chemistry model. This study seemed almost being forgotten as it was cited only 4 times since 1997.

This reaction forms gas-phase HOOCl which should be subsequently photo-dissociated likely rather quickly. Already in 1977, before the discovery of the ozone hole, Peter Warneck discussed the potential role of this molecule. However, comprehensive laboratory measurements for the chemical kinetics for the proposed newly added reactions have not been performed so far. In our modelling study, we could show that the heterogeneous reaction between Cl2O and HCl is indeed able to deplete the HCl in the polar vortex core as observed. The figure below shows the HCl comparison for the two cases where the reaction was either omitted and included in comparison with satellite data from MLS. Also the comparison with other chlorine compounds ClONO2, ClO and HOCl improves with the new chemistry.

Vortex core average simulated HCl and corresponding observations.
Vortex core average simulations of HCl and corresponding observations in about
21 km altitude. Red are the previous model results, orange those with the proposed 
additional reactions. Corresponding MLS satellite data are shown in blue.

The increase of active chlorine by over 50% in the model causes an increase of ozone depletion of by over 15% between early July and mid September. The simulated ozone depletion is not larger, since the difference in active chlorine occurs within the rather dark polar winter period, but it is still important for the better understanding of the recovery from the ozone hole, that is visible most prominent in September.

As the underlying physical chemistry of the new processes is unknown, we made plausible assumptions concerning rate coefficients and photolysis frequencies. We hope that this publication encourages detailed laboratory measurements of the  reaction kinetics of the proposed chemistry.

Please sign in or register for FREE

If you are a registered user on Research Communities by Springer Nature, please sign in

Follow the Topic

Atmospheric Chemistry
Physical Sciences > Earth and Environmental Sciences > Earth Sciences > Atmospheric Science > Atmospheric Chemistry
Atmospheric Science
Physical Sciences > Earth and Environmental Sciences > Earth Sciences > Atmospheric Science

Related Collections

With Collections, you can get published faster and increase your visibility.

Geology of the Moon

This collection focuses on the Geology of our Moon and new insights we gain from remote sensing data, meteorites and returned samples, and modeling efforts.

Publishing Model: Hybrid

Deadline: Jan 31, 2026

Drought

In this cross-journal Collection, we highlight studies that investigate the underlying causes and consequences of drought.

Publishing Model: Hybrid

Deadline: Dec 31, 2025