Lack of detection of a human placenta microbiome in samples from preterm and term deliveries
Published in Microbiology
Historically, it was believed that the contents of the gravid uterus (placenta, amniotic cavity, and fetus) are sterile, known as the “sterile womb hypothesis”. However, recent studies have proposed that the womb is not sterile and is instead inhabited by a distinct, commensal microbiome. These studies use modern DNA deep sequencing techniques to detect a low microbial biomass community. However, these studies often have a notable lack of sequenced matched samples (e.g. maternal saliva or vaginal samples) and thorough negative controls, which are crucial to differentiate between authentic organisms and reagent contamination. Our group performed 16S rRNA gene qPCR, 16S marker sequencing, and shotgun metagenomic sequencing on placenta samples from term and preterm deliveries alongside matched samples and negative controls to see if we could detect a placental microbiome.
With the help of the PennCHOP Microbiome Program, the Maternal and Child Health Research Center at UPenn, and March of Dimes, we analyzed samples from 20 term and 20 preterm pregnancies, including saliva, vaginal swabs, and maternal and fetal side placental biopsies. The qPCR data showed that the placenta samples had low bacterial abundance indistinguishable from the background seen in the negative control samples, unlike the high abundance seen in saliva and vaginal samples. In our 16S sequencing data, the placenta samples did initially show a low level of bacterial DNA—however, we found that a majority of the bacterial lineages seen in placenta were also found in our negative controls and are documented contaminants. Performing cluster analysis showed that the communities seen in the placenta samples were not different from those in the negative control samples. Shotgun metagenomics allowed us to deep sequence these samples for all of the DNA present. After filtering out the human reads present, we saw that the majority of the remaining sequences from the placenta samples were annotated as Ralstonia, a known reagent contaminant and also seen in the negative controls. After further investigation, the remaining placenta reads could be attributed to erroneous classifications. In conclusion, our group did not detect an microbiome in placenta samples are term or preterm deliveries.
While the experimental data from this study showed negative results, the experimental design and execution demonstrated the importance of including thorough negative controls—specifically in low biomass microbiome studies. With the advent of intensive DNA sequencing methods and their widespread use in microbiome studies, it is important to understand the pitfalls of these techniques. Furthermore, the lack of detection of a microbiome in the placenta is also an important contribution to the fields of obstetrics and gynecology. The microbiome plays an import role in human health, and understanding its relevance during pregnancy and fetal development is an important aspect of this field. Recent studies suggesting to have found a microbiome inside the womb have opened a new line of thought about bacterial colonization of humans. With reports supporting both sides of the “sterile womb hypothesis”, it is important that we have thorough scientific investigations that generate reproducible results before moving forward with further research. This study underscores the importance of incorporating rigorous controls in the detection of an intrauterine microbiome.
Full paper can be found here: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40168-018-0575-4
Artwork done by Arwa Abbas
Follow the Topic
-
Microbiome
This journal hopes to integrate researchers with common scientific objectives across a broad cross-section of sub-disciplines within microbial ecology. It covers studies of microbiomes colonizing humans, animals, plants or the environment, both built and natural or manipulated, as in agriculture.
Related Collections
With Collections, you can get published faster and increase your visibility.
Animal Gut Nutrition and Greenhouse Gas Mitigation
Animal Microbiome, Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology and Microbiome call for submissions to the collection on Animal Gut Nutrition and Greenhouse Gas Mitigation.
Efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from livestock systems increasingly hinge on innovations in animal gut nutrition. The dynamic relationship between the gut microbiome and nutrient utilization plays a pivotal role in shaping methane output, feed efficiency, and overall sustainability. Advances in microbial ecology—particularly in understanding the role of gut microbiome in nutrient metabolism—are opening new pathways for mitigating emissions while enhancing productivity. These developments support the implementation of climate-smart agricultural strategies to address climate change and its impacts.
Looking ahead, continued research in this field has the potential to yield innovative solutions such as targeted probiotic supplementation, which could further optimize gut function and enhance nutrient absorption. These advancements may lead to reduced greenhouse gas emissions while improving animal health and productivity. By deepening our understanding of the animal gut microbiome, we can contribute significantly to sustainable agricultural practices that benefit both the environment and food security.
We invite researchers to contribute to this special Collection on Animal Gut Nutrition and Greenhouse Gas Mitigation. Topics of interest include but are not limited to:
- Animal Gut Microbiome and Feed Efficiency
- Greenhouse Gas Mitigation Strategies
- Rumen Fermentation Dynamics
- Nutrient Utilization in Livestock
- Probiotic Supplementation Effects
- Sustainable Livestock Production Practices
- Climate-Smart Agriculture Innovations
This Collection supports and amplifies research related to SDG 13, Climate action.
All submissions in this collection undergo the relevant journal’s standard peer review process. Similarly, all manuscripts authored by a Guest Editor(s) will be handled by the Editor-in-Chief of the relevant journal. As an open access publication, participating journals levy an article processing fee (Animal Microbiome fees, Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology fees, Microbiome fees). We recognize that many key stakeholders may not have access to such resources and are committed to supporting participation in this issue wherever resources are a barrier. For more information about what support may be available, please visit OA funding and support, or email OAfundingpolicy@springernature.com or the Editor-in-Chief of the journal where the article is being submitted.
Publishing Model: Open Access
Deadline: Sep 04, 2026
Oncobiome
This collection of papers delves into the burgeoning field of oncobiome research, exploring the intricate relationship between cancer and the microbiome. The oncobiome encompasses the diverse microbial communities residing in and on the human body, which influence cancer development, progression, and treatment responses. By examining these interactions, our aim is to unravel the complex mechanisms through which the microbiome impacts oncogenesis and therapeutic outcomes.
This compilation highlights cutting-edge research, offering insights into potential diagnostic markers and novel therapeutic strategies, thereby advancing our understanding of cancer biology and paving the way for innovative, microbiome-targeted cancer treatments.
This is a cross-journal collection between:
Experimental Hematology and Oncology
Articles will undergo the standard peer-review process of the journal to which they are submitted and are subject to either the BMC editorial policies or those of BJC Reports. Articles will be added to the Collection as they are published. The Editors have no competing interests with the submissions which they handle through the peer review process. The peer review of any submissions for which the Editors have competing interests is handled by another Editorial Board Member who has no competing interests.
Publishing Model: Open Access
Deadline: Ongoing
Please sign in or register for FREE
If you are a registered user on Research Communities by Springer Nature, please sign in