Behind the Paper

Measuring What Truly Matters: A New Scale Blends Psychology and Spirituality to Redefine Effectiveness in Churches

Churches shape lives and communities, yet no reliable tool measures how effectively they do so. My study developed a psychologically informed scale to assess faith-based organisational effectiveness, bridging spiritual purpose with organisational performance.
Go to the profile of Dr. Abraham Nyako Jnr., DBA, MPH
Dr. Abraham Nyako Jnr., DBA, MPH
Organizational Development and Public Health Specialist, Individual consultant/researcher
Like
Go to the profile of India Ambler
Go to the profile of Yuanxin Zhang
Go to the profile of Dr. Abraham Nyako Jnr., DBA, MPH

Share this post

Choose a social network to share with, or copy the URL to share elsewhere

Share with...

...or copy the link

This is a representation of how your post may appear on social media. The actual post will vary between social networks

Explore the Research

SpringerLink
SpringerLink SpringerLink

Phase one preliminary validation of a psychologically informed scale for faith based organisational effectiveness - Discover Psychology

Background Organisational effectiveness (OE) is critical for faith-based organisations (FBOs), particularly churches, to fulfil their mission while advancing human development. Despite their societal influence, no existing tool adequately measures OE in faith-based contexts while integrating psychological dimensions. This study reports phase one of a two-phase project aimed at validating a 50-item, psychologically informed OE scale for churches in Ghana. Methods A sequential mixed-methods design was employed. A literature review and qualitative interviews with 20 experienced pastors and church leaders informed the generation of items. Expert review was conducted to ensure content and face validity. The resulting instrument was pilot-tested and administered to 844 participants across Protestant/Orthodox and Pentecostal/Charismatic churches. Exploratory factor analysis (EFA) established construct validity and internal consistency. Confirmatory factor analysis was deliberately deferred to phase two in order to follow established methodological guidance which recommends validation on a large independent sample to avoid statistical overfitting and inflated model fit indices. Results EFA supported a four-factor structure namely financial sustainability, operational efficiency, structural governance, and attitudinal engagement with strong internal consistency (Cronbach’s alpha: 0.874–0.957). The scale demonstrated potential for assessing OE in churches while capturing psychological and behavioural dimensions relevant to leadership, engagement, and community impact. Results also indicate the role of churches in character formation, leadership development, and membership retention. Cronbach’s α values exceeded 0.90, yet inter-item correlations (r = 0.15–0.50) remained largely optimal, showing strong coherence without redundancy. These findings establish a solid basis for confirmatory factor analysis in future research. Conclusion This study introduces the first empirically derived model of psychologically blended faith-based OE, providing a theoretical foundation for subsequent validation. A second phase will employ confirmatory factor analysis to evaluate model fit, validity, and generalisability across diverse organisational settings. The scale offers practical utility for church leaders seeking to enhance institutional performance and mission alignment.
Where It Began
My motivation for this study grew from extensive years of work in the non-governmental health and development sector. During this time, I saw how strong governance, management, and leadership systems determine organisational success. This inspired me to focus on churches as faith-based organisations that, beyond their spiritual roles, also provide vital social and economic services. I wanted to explore how these institutions could strengthen their structures and effectiveness without approaching them theologically, but as organisations with measurable systems and outcomes. This conviction set me on the path to develop and validate what would become a 50-item, psychologically informed scale for faith-based organisational effectiveness.
Building the Foundation
The first phase of the study began with a literature review and in-depth interviews with experienced pastors and church leaders. Their insights revealed not only administrative challenges but also the emotional and spiritual dynamics that sustain healthy church life- trust, motivation, and shared vision. Using their perspectives, I drafted initial scale items and subjected them to rigorous expert review to ensure both face and content validity. The study that followed included 844 participants drawn from Orthodox/Protestant and Pentecostal/Charismatic churches across Ghana. This was both exciting and humbling gathering data from such a diverse spiritual landscape meant navigating varying leadership structures, theological emphases, and cultural expectations. Yet amid these differences, one truth stood out: effective churches blend structure and spirit, governance and grace.
The Findings
Exploratory factor analysis (EFA) revealed a robust four-factor structure; financial sustainability, operational efficiency, structural governance, and attitudinal engagement. Together, these factors offered a holistic view of organisational effectiveness that integrates practical systems with psychological well-being and commitment. Internal consistency was strong (Cronbach’s alpha: 0.874–0.957), suggesting that the scale reliably captures these complex dimensions without redundancy. In essence, the results confirmed that faith-based organisational health can indeed be measured with both empirical rigour and spiritual sensitivity.
Lessons Learned
One of the most rewarding aspects of this journey was seeing how pastors and church leaders resonated with the research. Many expressed that the process itself prompted reflection on how their churches operate-not just as places of worship, but as living communities that must balance mission with management. The greatest challenge, however, lay in maintaining methodological purity while respecting theological diversity. Ensuring that the instrument remained both scientifically valid and spiritually authentic required continual dialogue and discernment.
Looking Ahead
This study lays the theoretical foundation for phase two, where confirmatory factor analysis will test model fit and generalisability using a larger, independent sample. My ultimate goal is to provide church leaders and researchers with a practical, evidence-based tool to assess and strengthen faith-based organisations from the inside out.
For me, this research is more than an academic exercise-it’s a bridge between faith and evidence, spirit and structure. It demonstrates that organisational effectiveness in churches is not only measurable but also improvable, when approached with both scientific care and spiritual understanding.
In a world where faith-based institutions continue to shape social and moral development, such tools can help ensure that their impact remains both sustainable and transformative.
Go to the profile of Dr. Abraham Nyako Jnr., DBA, MPH
Dr. Abraham Nyako Jnr., DBA, MPH
Organizational Development and Public Health Specialist, Individual consultant/researcher

I bring over two decades of leadership in public health, organizational development, and nonprofit capacity-building. My career has focused on strengthening organizational effectiveness, advancing sustainable governance models, and increasing impact across the nonprofit sector. I am passionate about helping mission-driven organizations improve governance, enhance operational efficiency, and achieve long-term sustainability.

Please sign in or register for FREE

If you are a registered user on Research Communities by Springer Nature, please sign in

Sign In Register

Follow the Topic

Organization and Leadership
Humanities and Social Sciences > Education > Skills > Organization and Leadership
Organizational Theory
Humanities and Social Sciences > Politics and International Studies > Public Policy > Public Management > Organizational Theory
Organizational Psychology
Humanities and Social Sciences > Behavioral Sciences and Psychology > Work and Organizational Psychology > Organizational Psychology
Faith, Spirituality and Business
Humanities and Social Sciences > Business and Management > Management > Business Ethics > Faith, Spirituality and Business

Related Collections

With Collections, you can get published faster and increase your visibility.

The Spectrum of Flourishing: Multiconceptual Approaches to Well-Being

This research collection delves into the multifaceted concept of well-being, exploring its diverse dimensions, cultural nuances, and interdisciplinary perspectives. Drawing on the latest advancements in psychology, sociology, political science, and health sciences, this collection seeks to unravel the complex interplay between individual, communal, and systemic factors contributing to human flourishing.

Contributors are encouraged to present innovative theories, empirical studies, and applied interventions that illuminate the pathways to achieving well-being across varied contexts. Topics of interest include, but are not limited to:

· Cultural and contextual factors shaping well-being paradigms

· The role of personal and collective resilience in flourishing

· Interventions fostering mental, emotional, and social well-being

· The impact of socio-economic and ecological systems on life outcomes

· Technological and digital tools in promoting holistic well-being

This collection aims to foster a deeper understanding of well-being as a dynamic and interconnected construct by embracing multi-conceptual approaches. It invites researchers, practitioners, and policymakers to challenge conventional perspectives and contribute to a richer, more inclusive discourse on what it means to flourish in diverse societies. Furthermore, it offers insights into the ever-evolving spectrum of well-being in a globalized world.

Keywords:Well-Being, Flourishing, Mental Health, Positive Psychology, Resilience, Cultural Norms, Life Satisfaction, Interdisciplinary Research, Health-Related Quality of Life (HrQoL), Social Cohesion

This Collection supports and amplifies research related to SDG 3, 5, 8, 10, and SDG 11.

Publishing Model: Open Access

Deadline: Sep 30, 2026

Explore this Collection

Mental Health and SDGs: Examining Interrelationships Between Mental Health and Agenda 2030

Mental health is integral to achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), as it intersects with all the global targets for Agenda 2030. The inclusion of mental health within Agenda 2030 reflects its importance for achieving global well-being and equity. However, the complex relationships between mental health and the SDGs are often underexplored. For instance, poor mental health can hinder educational attainment, economic productivity, and resilience to environmental crises, while systemic inequities, climate change, and conflict exacerbate mental health challenges globally.

Despite growing global commitments, the integration of mental health into development agendas remains fragmented. Research is often siloed, focusing on either mental health outcomes or SDG targets, rather than exploring their interdependencies. Furthermore, there is limited understanding of how mental health interventions can accelerate SDG achievements or how progress on the SDGs can promote mental well-being. Addressing these gaps is essential to building inclusive, sustainable communities where mental health and development reinforce one another.

This collection aims to provide a platform for interdisciplinary research that examines the interrelationships between mental health and the SDGs. We welcome studies that investigate how mental health issues influence progress on the SDGs and how development efforts can address mental health disparities. This collection will offer critical insights for policymakers, practitioners, and researchers working to integrate mental health into global development strategies.

Key Themes Include (but are not limited to):

• Mental Health and Overall Health and Well-Being: Exploring mental health as a core component of health and well-being, including the integration of mental health services into primary healthcare.

• Educational Outcomes and Mental Health: Investigating the effects of mental health on learning, school attendance, and academic performance, and vice versa.

• Gender Equality and Mental Health: Examining the mental health implications of gender disparities, violence, and empowerment.

• Climate Change and Mental Health: Assessing the psychological impacts of climate-related events and the role of mental health in building climate resilience.

• Mental Health Inequities and SDG Progress: Exploring how disparities in access to mental health care affect progress on the SDGs, especially for marginalized groups.

• Resilience and Sustainable Development: Identifying protective factors and community-based strategies that enhance mental health and promote sustainable development.

• Digital Innovations and Mental Health in SDG Achievement: Evaluating the role of technology in addressing mental health challenges within development contexts.

• Mental Health Policy and the SDGs: Analyzing policies that integrate mental health into national and international development agendas.

• Youth Mental Health and SDGs: Investigating the intersection of youth mental health with education, employment, and civic participation.

• Intersectionality in Mental Health and SDGs: Exploring how intersecting identities (e.g., age, gender, socio-economic status, ethnicity) influence mental health outcomes and development goals.

Keywords: Mental Health and Sustainable Development Goals; Global Mental Health and SDGs; Mental Health Equity; Climate and Mental Health; Resilience and Well-being; Mental Health Policy and Advocacy; Education and Mental Health; Gender and Mental Health; Vulnerable Populations; Interdisciplinary Development and Mental Health.

This Collection supports and amplifies research related to all the SDGs.

Publishing Model: Open Access

Deadline: Jun 30, 2026

Explore this Collection

Recommended Content

Cookies

We use cookies to ensure the functionality of our website, to personalize content and advertising, to provide social media features, and to analyze our traffic. If you allow us to do so, we also inform our social media, advertising and analysis partners about your use of our website. You can decide for yourself which categories you want to deny or allow. Please note that based on your settings not all functionalities of the site are available.

Further information can be found in our privacy policy.

Cookie Control

Customise your preferences for any tracking technology

The following allows you to customize your consent preferences for any tracking technology used to help us achieve the features and activities described below. To learn more about how these trackers help us and how they work, refer to the cookie policy. You may review and change your preferences at any time.

See the full cookie policy See the full privacy policy
More information

These trackers are used for activities that are strictly necessary to operate or deliver the service you requested from us and, therefore, do not require you to consent.

More information

These trackers help us to deliver personalized marketing content and to operate, serve and track ads.

More information

These trackers help us to deliver personalized marketing content to you based on your behaviour and to operate, serve and track social advertising.

More information

These trackers help us to measure traffic and analyze your behaviour with the goal of improving our service.

More information

These trackers help us to provide a personalized user experience by improving the quality of your preference management options, and by enabling the interaction with external networks and platforms.