How Human Networks Adapt Under Pressure: Insights from Synchronization Experiments

When human networks face disruptions like disasters or pandemics, they must adapt to find stability. Our study, using violin players, reveals three unique strategies that emerge within a network under stress, offering insights into how societies self-organize and restore harmony amid crises.
How Human Networks Adapt Under Pressure: Insights from Synchronization Experiments
Like

Share this post

Choose a social network to share with, or copy the URL to share elsewhere

This is a representation of how your post may appear on social media. The actual post will vary between social networks

In any human society, connections form a complex network through which ideas, beliefs, and information flow. Within this web, people make decisions, share news, and form collective actions. However, what happens when such a network encounters a disturbance? Wars, natural disasters, or pandemics can throw the network into disarray, forcing individuals and the network itself to adapt to new conditions.

Our research explores how human networks adapt to disruptions, leaving an imperfect state to seek a new, optimal one. To investigate, we set up a unique experiment with 16 violin players, each performing the same musical phrase repeatedly. We could fully control the connectivity between each player and adjust the delay in their communication. At first, the players were synchronized, playing together. Then, we introduced delay, disturbing the synchronized state and creating "frustration" in the network. This delay caused the network’s synchronized state to become unsustainable; without a conductor, the musicians had to find a new stable state on their own. The solution turned out to be a "vortex state synchronization," where each player adjusted in response to others.

Through this experiment, we observed that when faced with frustration, the network employed three main dynamics to reach an optimal state:

  1. Selective Disregard of Inputs: Some players began to ignore external signals, focusing only on their internal rhythm. This allowed the network to shift naturally into a better state as they adjusted within the new parameters.

  2. Slowdown and Oscillation Death: Others clung to the imperfect synchronized state, but delays caused them to gradually slow until they reached "oscillation death," a condition where they played a single note continuously. 

  3. Temporary Withdrawal: A few players stopped playing altogether, waiting for the network to stabilize before rejoining. 

These patterns of response closely resemble dynamics we see in other natural systems under stress, from ecosystems to economies. By studying these adaptive responses, we gain insight into how networks—whether of people, information, or resources—can adjust and self-organize in pursuit of stability, even without centralized guidance.

Our findings could inform fields ranging from disaster response to social planning, shedding light on the pathways that networks take to self-organize and find stability after a disruption. Through this understanding, we can better prepare for future crises and perhaps even shape systems that respond more resiliently in the face of unexpected change.

Please sign in or register for FREE

If you are a registered user on Research Communities by Springer Nature, please sign in

Follow the Topic

Complex Networks
Physical Sciences > Physics and Astronomy > Theoretical, Mathematical and Computational Physics > Complex Systems > Complex Networks
Decision Making
Humanities and Social Sciences > Behavioral Sciences and Psychology > Social Psychology > Cognition > Decision Making
Leadership Psychology
Humanities and Social Sciences > Behavioral Sciences and Psychology > Work and Organizational Psychology > Leadership Psychology
Complex Networks
Physical Sciences > Physics and Astronomy > Classical and Continuum Physics > Continuum Mechanics > Fluid Mechanics > Dynamical Systems > Complex Networks
Complex Systems
Physical Sciences > Physics and Astronomy > Theoretical, Mathematical and Computational Physics > Complex Systems
Signal Processing
Life Sciences > Biological Sciences > Biological Techniques > Computational and Systems Biology > Systems Biology > Signal Processing

Related Collections

With collections, you can get published faster and increase your visibility.

Cancer epigenetics

With this cross-journal Collection, the editors at Nature Communications, Communications Biology, Communications Medicine, and Scientific Reports invite submissions covering the breadth of research carried out in the field of cancer epigenetics. We will highlight studies aiming at the improvement of our understanding of the epigenetic mechanisms underlying cancer initiation, progression, response to therapy, metastasis and tumour plasticity as well as findings that have the potential to be translated into the clinic.

Publishing Model: Open Access

Deadline: Jan 31, 2025

Clinical trials

In this call for papers, Nature Communications invites submissions of papers reporting interventional trials, including those yielding negative results for which primary end-points were not met.

Publishing Model: Open Access

Deadline: Dec 31, 2024