Variable levels of introgression between the endangered Podarcis carbonelli and highly divergent congeneric species

When an endangered species occurs in sympatry across nearly its entire distribution with at least one other congeneric species, and reproductive isolation is incomplete between them, what can be the consequences of widespread hybridization for the endangered species persistence?
Published in Ecology & Evolution
Variable levels of introgression between the endangered Podarcis carbonelli and highly divergent congeneric species

Based on evidence from previous studies1,2,3 that our study system – the Podarcis hispanicus complex, a lizard clade comprised of deeply divergent species (about 2.5 to 10 Mya) – shows signs of both recent and historical admixture, one of the main objectives of my PhD was to identify isolation mechanisms and their similarity (or not) across species. To do so, we assessed the degree of reproductive isolation, using SNP data from RAD sequencing and linking genetic data to species traits.

Male specimens of each species included in this study. From left to right: Podarcis carbonelli, Podarcis bocagei, Podarcis virescens, Podarcis guadarramae lusitanicus, Podarcis vaucheri. Credits: Guilherme Caeiro-Dias.

Quite often new questions arise when a project is already ongoing. We started to collect samples in 2013, and by 2015 we had RADseq data for seven contact zones. Four of these contact zones involved Carbonell´s wall lizard (Podarcis carbonelli) and another Podarcis species. Preliminary analysis revealed the presence of hybrids in three contact zones. These findings triggered the questions: does Podarcis carbonelli hybridize with all co-occurring Podarcis species? If yes, considering that Podarcis carbonelli is currently listed as endangered and contacts with at least one other Podarcis species across most of its distribution range, can hybridization threaten its persistence?

From a conservation point of view, the negative effects of hybridization on the genomic integrity of endangered species raise obvious concerns. However, introgressive hybridization has also been growingly recognized as a potential source of diversity and favourable novel genetic variants. In this study we proposed to compare the strength of reproductive isolation between Podarcis carbonelli and its sympatric congeners to evaluate the relevance of hybridization in a “Podarcis carbonelli context”.

Our results clearly indicated incomplete reproductive isolation and ongoing gene flow between most species, with variable dynamics of hybridization between species pairs, suggesting complex interactions between multiple intrinsic and extrinsic reproductive barriers. Also, interspecific gene flow is not restricted to recent generations and seems ubiquitous, but we found evidences of strong reproductive isolation. These results suggest that hybridization may be part of evolutionary history of Podarcis carbonelli and not a threat to its genomic integrity. However, the indirect effects of hybridization (i.e., waste of reproductive effort in small isolated populations) may still be problematic for the persistence Podarcis carbonelli.

Results of Principal Component Analysis of SNP variation for each contact zone studied (panels a-d) and schematic tree with phylogenetic relationships of Podarcis hispanicus complex lineages, with species analyzed in this study highlighted and time to most recent common ancestor represented (panel e). Figure 2 in the paper.

An interesting finding was that Podarcis carbonelli and the closest related species show the strongest reproductive isolation, share the most extensive sympatric distribution and inhabit the exact same microhabitat in the analysed contact zone; meanwhile Podarcis carbonelli and the more distantly related species show the highest levels of introgression, have a very restricted sympatric distribution overlap and present the most obvious segregation at the microhabitat level. This led us suggest that reinforcement may play a central role in enhancing reproductive isolation, not only between the species studied here, but across the entire Podarcis hispanicus complex. This is a question that we will address in the near future.

We think that these findings will add important insights on the potential effects of hybridization and introgression for endangered species, but further evaluation of the genomic consequences of introgression is crucial.

Check out the paper here.

Please sign in or register for FREE

If you are a registered user on Research Communities by Springer Nature, please sign in